Zemfira in Montana. Vogelmetaphorik, ‚going native‘ und koloniale Apologetik von „Cygany“ (1824) zu „Yellowstone“ (2018–2024)
Published 2026-10-02
Keywords
- Pushkin,
- Bizet,
- “Carmen”,
- transimperiality,
- settler colonialism
Abstract
This essay interprets Taylor Sheridan’s Yellowstone (2018–2024) and its prequels as a reimagining of the transimperial legitimation poetics that frame Romani and Indigenous otherness as heterotopic spaces of freedom. In Yellowstone, colonial violence is portrayed as an original sin from which redemption can be found through going native, thereby leading to a genealogical fusion with the land and the appropriation of Indigenous suffering. The argument focuses on the doubly coded symbolism of birds that function simultaneously as symbols of freedom and as emblems of imperial sovereignty. Through an intertextual reading of Yellowstone alongside Bizet’s Carmen and Pushkin’s Tsygany (The Gypsies), a transimperial practice of rewriting is traced, with Carmen serving as the link between Pushkin’s colonial poetics and Sheridan’s neo-Western. In both imperial formations, colonial violence is transformed into a narrative of loss centered on the colonizers, while symbolic indigenization transforms conquest into belonging and domination into redemption. The blonde Dutton daughters appear in Yellowstone as embodiments of Manifest Destiny, which, as this essay argues, can be traced structurally back to Aleko and Zemfira in Tsygany. From this perspective, Yellowstone is not only a revisionist Western but also a contemporary variant of a much older imperial grammar. The analysis reveals a clear similarity between the apologetic structures of Manifest Destiny, on the one hand, and the central legitimizing narratives of the Russian Empire, on the other.
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2026 Gesine Drews-Sylla (Autor/in)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.